Parallax Mission control
Issue 08 · live Subscribe
Subscribe

Mission control · No 08

The odds moved. The asteroid did not.

An asteroid's chance of hitting Earth once read 1 in 32. Six days later, 1 in 25,000. The rock you were watching never moved.

Published
4 Jun 2026
Reading time
4 min
Sources
8 cited
Sections
6
In this issue · 6 sections
  1. 01 One common misread
  2. 02 Fifteen-month arc
  3. 03 Three words first
  4. 04 Said out loud
  5. 05 Every number
  6. 06 In their own

Before you start

In December 2024 a telescope in Chile found this rock. For fifteen months its odds of a hit rose, then fell to zero. Here is what actually changed.

01 · ONE COMMON MISREAD

One rock, two very different numbers

What most people think

The odds kept getting revised down, so the whole thing must have been an overreaction that scientists quietly walked back.

What the data shows

Those are the odds of an Earth impact, six days apart in February 2025. The asteroid flew the same orbit through both readings, so only the measurement changed: how well anyone knew where it would be.

The risk then moved to the Moon and rose there, before going to zero as well.

The odds of hitting Earth fell from 3.1% to 0.004% between 18 and 24 February 2025.

Source · NASA Planetary Defense blog

02 · A FIFTEEN-MONTH ARC

Up on Earth, across to the Moon, zero

That six-day drop was one step in a longer sequence. Read the dates downward and the same orbit sits under every reading.

  1. Dec 27 2024

    Found by ATLAS, in Chile. The first report of this rock, from a survey telescope NASA funds.

  2. Feb 18 2025

    Earth-impact odds peak at 3.1%. Peak odds. The orbit was at its least known.

  3. Feb 24 2025

    Earth ruled out. Odds 0.004%. The odds are split across whatever is still inside the range of possible positions. Earth now falls outside it. The Moon is still inside, at 1.7%.

  4. Jun 3 2025

    Lunar odds climb to 4.3%. The range keeps shrinking with the Moon inside it, so the Moon's share of that smaller space rises. Then the rock fades from view. The risk moves to the Moon. The rock does not.

  5. Feb 18 & 26 2026

    Webb makes two faint detections. Webb, a space telescope, made these two detections. The astronomers who led them said it reflects 'about as much light as an almond at the distance of the Moon.'

  6. Mar 5 2026

    Lunar impact ruled out. Zero. Two nights of Webb put the Moon outside that range too, two years before any ground telescope could have. It passes more than 20,000 km clear.

Six dated updates for 2024 YR4. The arc runs from the December 2024 discovery to the March 2026 all-clear.

Source · NASA Planetary Defense and Webb blogs, with ESA

03 · THREE WORDS FIRST

What these percentages were actually measuring

The sequence you just read is six readings of one orbit. Three terms explain why the readings moved.

The error box. The stretch of space the asteroid could be in on the day. Every fresh sighting shrinks it, and the odds are split across what is left inside.

Impact probability. The odds that the rock hits us, written as a percentage. It tracks the size of that box, so sharper measurements move the number while the rock stays put.

The 1% line. Crossing one percent starts the international planetary-defence notification process. It is a procedure that switches on, nothing more.

Source · NASA Planetary Defense blog

04 · SAID OUT LOUD

3.1% is about one chance in thirty-two

A percentage is hard to feel. Here is the peak Earth figure, said the way odds usually are.

The peak Earth reading of 3.1% is about one chance in thirty-two. Turned around, that is thirty-one chances in thirty-two that nothing happens.

Source · NASA Planetary Defense blog

05 · EVERY NUMBER AT ONCE

Only one of six belongs to the rock

Those odds describe how well we knew the orbit, so they moved. The size is the one figure here that belongs to the rock itself. The date and the distance belong to the close approach.

Peak Earth-impact odds: 3.1 %. Set on 18 February 2025, when the orbit was known least well.

Earth odds after resolution: 0.004 %. Six days later. Earth is out, for 2032 and beyond.

Peak lunar-impact odds: 4.3 %. 3 June 2025, the high point. Europe's space agency later called it around 4%.

Estimated diameter: 53–67 m. The miss distance is three to four lakh times this width.

Miss distance from the Moon: >20,000 km. The other published figure puts it 21,200 km above the lunar surface.

Close-approach date: Dec 22 2032. The single date every probability above was a reading for.

Asteroid 2024 YR4 · key figures, Dec 2024 to Mar 2026

Source · NASA Planetary Defense blogs and 2024 YR4 Facts, with ESA Planetary Defence

06 · IN THEIR OWN WORDS

NASA's own sentence for what changed

Six numbers, and only the size was about the rock. Here is how the agency put it.

This update reflects improved precision in our understanding of where the asteroid is expected to be in 2032 rather than a shift in its orbital path.

Molly Wasser, NASA Science

'Improved precision' means the range of possible positions kept shrinking, so the Moon ended up outside it. The rock is still up there, in the same aasmaan, on the same path it has always flown. On 22 December 2032 it arrives, and it misses.

Source · NASA Planetary Defense blog · 5 March 2026

Reader signal

How did this land?

A private signal to the editor. Pick as many as apply — nobody else sees it, and it shapes what runs next.

Letters

Sixty days of argument.

Longer responses from readers. The editor reads each one before it appears here.

No letters yet Newest first

Be the first to write one. Letters open for sixty days after an issue is published.

Write a letter

0 / 2000 · reviewed before it appears

Sources

8 cited.

Every number above traces to one of these. Primary sources first.

  1. 01 New NASA Asteroid Observations Eliminate Chance of 2032 Lunar Impact science.nasa.gov NASA Science · Planetary Defense blog · primary
  2. 02 Asteroid 2024 YR4 will not impact the Moon esa.int European Space Agency · Planetary Defence · primary
  3. 03 Dark Skies Bring New Observations of Asteroid 2024 YR4, Lower Impact Probability science.nasa.gov NASA Science · Planetary Defense blog · primary
  4. 04 Latest Calculations Conclude Asteroid 2024 YR4 Now Poses No Significant Threat to Earth in 2032 and Beyond science.nasa.gov NASA Science · Planetary Defense blog · primary
  5. 05 NASA Update on the Size Estimate and Lunar Impact Probability of Asteroid 2024 YR4 science.nasa.gov NASA Science · Planetary Defense blog · primary
  6. 06 NASA's Webb Observations Update Asteroid 2024 YR4's Lunar Impact Odds science.nasa.gov NASA Science · Planetary Defense blog · primary
  7. 07 How NASA's Webb Helped Rule Out Asteroid's Chance of 2032 Lunar Impact science.nasa.gov NASA Science · Webb blog · primary
  8. 08 Asteroid 2024 YR4 Facts science.nasa.gov NASA Science · primary
0% · 4 min left
Press S

One email. Two things.

The dispatch when each issue ships — and a free shelf that saves your place. One click in your inbox does both.

Enable JavaScript to subscribe.